Skip to content

United States · Top 3

The 3 best hotels in Cape May.

One budget, one best value and one luxury hotel, picked from 9 hotels with live rates within 2 km of the centre. No endless list.

From €111 a night: the budget pick is Montreal Beach Resort, the best-value pick is ICONA Cape May and the luxury pick is Virginia Hotel.

Montreal Beach Resort, Cape May
Budget
4.5€111 / night

Montreal Beach Resort

Good forSwimming · Road trips

★★★★590 m from the centre
  • Guest rating 4.5/5 from 1,023 reviews
  • about 10 min on foot from the centre
  • Chosen from 9 hotels with live rates
  • a pool
  • a gym
  • a restaurant
  • parking

Address: 1025 Beach Avenue · Open in Google Maps
Check-in from 04:00 PM, check-out until 11:00 AM

Reference rateabout €222 for 2 nights

Seen for 15 Dec 2026 to 17 Dec 2026, 2 adults, 1 room. Check today’s price for your dates.

Check price & availability ↗
ICONA Cape May, Cape May
Best Value
5.0€155 / night

ICONA Cape May

Good forFamilies · Swimming · Road trips

★★★★260 m from the centre
  • Guest rating 5.0/5 from 1,089 reviews
  • about 4 min on foot from the centre
  • Chosen from 9 hotels with live rates
  • a pool
  • parking
  • air conditioning
  • family rooms

Address: 1101 Beach Avenue · Open in Google Maps
Check-in from 03:00 PM, check-out until 10:00 AM

Reference rateabout €310 for 2 nights

Seen for 15 Dec 2026 to 17 Dec 2026, 2 adults, 1 room. Check today’s price for your dates.

Check price & availability ↗
Virginia Hotel, Cape May
Luxury
4.7€353 / night

Virginia Hotel

Good forSwimming · Road trips

★★★★1.5 km from the centre
  • Guest rating 4.7/5 from 145 reviews
  • about 24 min on foot from the centre
  • Chosen from 9 hotels with live rates
  • a pool
  • a gym
  • breakfast

Address: 25 Jackson Street, Cape May, New Jersey, 08204 · Open in Google Maps
Check-in from 03:00 PM, check-out until 11:00 AM

Reference rateabout €706 for 2 nights

Seen for 15 Dec 2026 to 17 Dec 2026, 2 adults, 1 room. Check today’s price for your dates.

Check price & availability ↗

Compare the three

BudgetBest ValueLuxury
HotelsMontreal Beach ResortICONA Cape MayVirginia Hotel
Price a night€111€155€353
Guest rating4.5/55.0/54.7/5
Stars444
From the centre590 m260 m1.5 km

About the three picks in Cape May

We compared 9 hotels with live rates within 2 km of the centre of Cape May and kept three. The budget pick, Montreal Beach Resort, is 590 m from the centre; the best-value pick, ICONA Cape May, is 260 m; and the luxury pick, Virginia Hotel, is 1.5 km. Reference prices run from about €111 to €353 a night for two adults, a difference of roughly €242 per night. Guest ratings range from 4.5 to 5.0 out of 5, across 2,257 reviews in total. The luxury pick has 4 stars. Listed facilities include a pool, a gym, a restaurant, parking, air conditioning. Nearby destinations with their own three picks: Atlantic City (63 km), Philadelphia (115 km), Annapolis (141 km).

Map of our three picks in Cape MayMontreal Beach ResortICONA Cape MayVirginia HotelCentre200 m
Positions from hotel coordinates. The square marks the centre of Cape May. Scale bar is approximate.

Questions about hotels in Cape May

Which is the best hotel in Cape May?

Our luxury pick is Virginia Hotel, rated 4.7/5 by guests. For the best balance of quality and price we pick ICONA Cape May.

Which is the best cheap hotel in Cape May?

Montreal Beach Resort: around €111 a night in our latest check, rated 4.5/5 by guests, 590 m from the centre.

How do you choose?

We look at hotels with live rates within a few kilometres of the centre, keep those with good guest ratings and enough reviews, and pick one per price level. Hotels cannot pay to be included.

Is there a 5-star hotel among the picks in Cape May?

No hotel with 5 stars met our rating rules in Cape May, so the luxury pick is Virginia Hotel with 4 stars.

How far are the hotels from the centre of Cape May?

Montreal Beach Resort is 590 m from the centre, ICONA Cape May is 260 m and Virginia Hotel is 1.5 km.

Which of the three has a pool or a spa?

Montreal Beach Resort (a pool); ICONA Cape May (a pool); Virginia Hotel (a pool).

When were these prices checked?

On 22 Nov 2026, for 15 Dec 2026 to 17 Dec 2026, two adults, one room.

More destinations near Cape May

Sources: live hotel rates, guest ratings and hotel facilities from our rates provider, checked on 22 Nov 2026. Prices are for reference and change daily; the booking site shows the final price. How we choose · Something wrong on this page? Tell us