Pitlochry: our three hotels side by side

Our three hotel picks in Pitlochry side by side: guest score, reviews, stars, area and reference price per night.

	Budget Fisher's Hotel	Best Value The Atholl Palace	Luxury Fonab Castle Hotel
Guest score	8.0/10	8.3/10	8.5/10
Reviews	3,050	2,000	1,041
Stars	★★★★	★★★★	★★★★★
Area	The Top-rated Area in Pitlochry	The Top-rated Area in Pitlochry	Foss Road
Reference price per night	€135	€242	€345
Guests like		Location: Historic castle set in large gardens with views and a short walk to town. Breakfast: Buffet selection includes Scottish items and is served in a room with scenic views.	Staff: Friendly, helpful, and attentive team provide a warm welcome, often in traditional attire. Location: Stunning setting with beautiful views over the loch and easy access to town.
Guests mention		Value For Money: High prices for rooms and drinks do not match the dated facilities.	Breakfast: High quality food and delicious options, though service is often slow and disorganized.
Good for	family, breakfast	pool, family, spa, parking, gym, breakfast	pool, pets, family, spa, parking, gym, breakfast

Which one?

Choose Fisher's Hotel if price matters most, The Atholl Palace for the best balance of score and price, and Fonab Castle Hotel if you want the best-reviewed upscale stay.

See all three picks

Prices are reference rates for a 2-night stay for 2 adults (10 to 12 Nov 2026), not live quotes. Scores and review counts are Booking.com snapshots from September 2026. Always check the current price before quoting it as today's.