The Knickerbocker Hotel
By the Top3Hotels editorial team. Based on Booking.com guest scores and reviews, location data and reference prices. We did not stay at this hotel. Updated 2026-10-22.
This is New York luxury for travellers who want to be steps from Times Square and value location above all else. The high price (€547/night reference rate) buys you a five-star address and professional service, but guests consistently say amenities and rooms do not justify the cost.
Check prices on Booking.com ↗We may earn a commission if you book. It never changes our pick.
Sold out? See available alternatives →Who it suits and who should skip
The Knickerbocker works for first-time visitors who want a postcard location and are willing to pay heavily for it. Broadway theatres, Rockefeller Center and subway lines are within minutes on foot. Families can book family rooms, and pets are permitted (check conditions and fees).
Skip it if you are budget-conscious or expect five-star amenities to match the five-star rate. Guests repeatedly mention that room size, dining prices and what you get for the money fall short. If location matters less, our Best Value pick (Hampton Inn Times Square Central, €431/night) scores identically at 8.6/10 and costs €116 less per night.
Location and getting around
The hotel sits at 6 Times Square in Manhattan. Times Square itself is a 3-minute walk (200 metres). Madison Square Garden is 10 minutes on foot (800 metres). Guests rate the location 9.5 out of 10.
Subway stations are close by, putting most of Manhattan within easy reach. For sights further out, taxis and rideshares pick up easily in this area. Walking times are straight-line estimates; confirm routes and transport options for your specific plans.
What guests say
The hotel scores 8.7 out of 10 from 2,217 reviews. Guests consistently praise the central Times Square setting and proximity to subway and attractions. The staff earn positive mentions: friendly, professional and attentive housekeeping.
The main complaint is value for money. Guests say nightly rates and on-site dining charges are steep for what is delivered, and that limited amenities do not meet five-star expectations. This is the clearest pattern in the feedback.
Price and what you get
Reference price for 10 to 12 November 2026 is €547 per night for two adults in one room. That is €144 above the sample median of €403 for New York hotels in the provider data.
For comparison, our Budget pick (Pod Times Square, €244/night) and Best Value pick (Hampton Inn Times Square Central, €431/night) both score 8.6/10. The Knickerbocker scores higher at 8.7, but the difference is marginal. You are paying an extra €116 to €303 per night for the five-star label and the exact Times Square address.
Breakfast is available as a buffet; confirm cost and inclusion when booking. The hotel has a restaurant, gym and free Wi-Fi. Room size, noise levels, cancellation terms and whether breakfast is included in your rate are not confirmed and must be checked.
Why it made our top three
The Knickerbocker was chosen as the Luxury pick after comparing 20 eligible properties. It tied for first place by review score (8.7/10) and holds official five-star status, which is prioritised for the Luxury slot.
The 9.5/10 location score is exceptional. If being on Times Square is non-negotiable, this delivers. The question is whether that address justifies the premium over hotels a few blocks away.
Before you book
Check your room type, size and view. Guest feedback suggests rooms may be smaller than expected for a five-star property. Confirm noise levels if you are sensitive; Times Square is loud at all hours.
Verify breakfast cost, cancellation policy and any pet fees. Ask about renovation dates and room condition, as these are not confirmed in the data. Compare the total price with our other two picks to decide whether the location premium is worth it for your trip.
Check prices on Booking.com ↗We may earn a commission if you book. It never changes our pick.
Sold out? See available alternatives →Questions travellers ask
Is The Knickerbocker Hotel worth the price?
Guests consistently say no: the 8.7/10 score is solid, but the €547/night reference rate does not match the limited amenities or room size. You are paying for the Times Square address, not five-star facilities.
How far is The Knickerbocker from Times Square?
The hotel is directly on Times Square, about 200 metres or 3 minutes on foot. The location scores 9.5 out of 10 from guests.
Does The Knickerbocker Hotel allow pets?
Yes, pets are permitted. Check fees, size limits and any deposit requirements when you book.
What do guests dislike about The Knickerbocker?
The main complaint is value for money. Guests say room rates and dining prices are high for what is provided, and that amenities fall short of five-star standards.