The Pfister Hotel
By the Top3Hotels editorial team. Based on Booking.com guest scores and reviews, location data and reference prices. We did not stay at this hotel. Updated 2026-10-24.
Worth booking if you want the best-rated hotel we compared in Milwaukee and you plan to explore downtown on foot. If you are driving or counting every euro, the parking costs and a price well above the city median may push you to our other two picks.
Check prices on Booking.com ↗We may earn a commission if you book. It never changes our pick.
Sold out? See available alternatives →Who it suits and who should skip it
This is our Luxury choice for Milwaukee. It suits couples and city-break travellers who put service and location first. Guests describe a friendly, professional team, a warm welcome and helpful service.
Pet owners should also take a look, since the hotel is tagged as pet friendly. Ask about any fee or size limit before you arrive, because those terms are not in our data.
Skip it if you are arriving by car and want to keep costs down. The one recurring complaint is the high price of overnight parking. Skip it too if your budget is tight: the reference price is far above the typical rate in the city.
Location and getting around
The address is 424 East Wisconsin Avenue, downtown. The location score is 9.8 out of 10, the strongest number in this hotel's profile. Reviewers say the lake, museums and restaurants are all walkable.
The Milwaukee Art Museum is about 0.7 km away, roughly 9 minutes on foot. Fiserv Forum is about 1.2 km, around 15 minutes.
The Basilica of St. Josaphat is a different story. At 4.2 km, about 53 minutes on foot, it is far, so plan on public transport or a taxi. Keep in mind that all walking times here are straight-line estimates and real routes can take longer.
What guests say
The score is 9.5 out of 10 from 877 reviews. That placed it first among the 10 eligible hotels in our sample.
Two themes come up again and again. First, the staff: guests call the team friendly and professional and mention a warm welcome. Second, the central downtown position, close to the lake and the museums.
The weak point is money. Room rates are seen as reasonable, but overnight parking is called expensive. If you drive, budget for it.
Price and how it compares with our other Milwaukee picks
The reference price was €202.84 per night, about €405.68 for two nights. This is a reference price seen for a 2-night stay in November 2026 for 2 adults, not a live quote. Check today's price for your own dates.
For context, the sample median was €114.97 per night, so this hotel costs much more than a typical room in our sample. Our Best Value pick, Drury Plaza Hotel Milwaukee Downtown, scored 9.0 at €122.39. Our Budget pick, Ambassador Hotel Milwaukee, Trademark Collection by Wyndham, scored 8.5 at €80.28. All three are 4-star.
What the extra money buys is the top guest score of the group, the best location rating and a property that lists a spa, a gym, a pool and a restaurant. Breakfast is tagged but the type and whether it is included are not confirmed.
Why it made our top 3
We compared 10 eligible hotels in Milwaukee. For the Luxury slot, five-star hotels get priority, and a four-star hotel only qualifies if it scores at least 8.5. The Pfister holds an official 4-star rating and scores 9.5, well above that bar.
It also ranked first on guest score in the whole sample.
Before you book
Our data does not cover room size, noise, renovation condition, breakfast inclusion or cancellation terms.
Check opening times and any fees for the spa, gym and pool for your dates, since the property lists them but availability is not confirmed. If you drive, ask for the current overnight parking rate. If you bring a pet, confirm the pet policy in writing.
Check prices on Booking.com ↗We may earn a commission if you book. It never changes our pick.
Sold out? See available alternatives →Questions travellers ask
Is The Pfister Hotel within walking distance of the Milwaukee Art Museum?
Yes. It is about 0.7 km away, roughly 9 minutes on foot as a straight-line estimate.
How much does The Pfister Hotel cost per night?
The reference price was €202.84 per night for 2 adults, seen for a 2-night stay in November 2026. Prices change, so check today's rate for your dates.
Does The Pfister Hotel have parking?
Guests mention overnight parking but say it is expensive. Ask the hotel for the current rate before you arrive.
Is The Pfister Hotel pet friendly?
It is tagged as pet friendly. Fees, size limits and rules are not confirmed in our data, so check with the hotel before booking.
Is breakfast included at The Pfister Hotel?
Breakfast is listed among the hotel's features, but the type and whether it is included in your rate are not confirmed. Check your booking terms.