Home › United Kingdom › Edinburgh › ibis Styles Edinburgh St Andrew Square vs Gleneagles Townhouse

Edinburgh, United Kingdom · Head to head

ibis Styles Edinburgh St Andrew Square vs Gleneagles Townhouse.

Two of our three Edinburgh picks compared on the numbers: the Best Value pick against the Luxury pick.

Gleneagles Townhouse has the higher guest score (9.4/10 from 451 reviews against 8.8 for ibis Styles Edinburgh St Andrew Square). ibis Styles Edinburgh St Andrew Square is cheaper: €184 a night against €571 (rate checked on 21 Nov 2026 for 15–17 Dec 2026, 2 adults, 1 room). ibis Styles Edinburgh St Andrew Square is closer to Edinburgh Castle (about 12 min on foot).

Scores and reference rates: Booking.com, checked 14 Oct 2026. Prices: rate checked on 21 Nov 2026 for 15–17 Dec 2026, 2 adults, 1 room; not live quotes.

Side by side

ibis Styles Edinburgh St Andrew SquareGleneagles Townhouse
Our pickBest ValueLuxury
AreaEdinburghEdinburgh
Stars3 (official)5 (official)
Guest score8.89.4
Reviews6,035451
Location score9.89.8
Reference rate / night€184€571
Price check 21 Nov 2026 (15–17 Dec 2026)€184€571
To Edinburgh Castle762 m · 12 min833 m · 14 min
To Scottish National Gallery416 m · 7 min434 m · 7 min
To Church of Scotland537 m · 9 min527 m · 9 min
Pets allowedYesYes
Family roomsYesYes
SpaNot listedYes
Fitness centreNot listedYes
Breakfast availableYesYes
Air conditioningYesYes

The two hotels are about 196 m apart.

Best Value pick

Choose ibis Styles Edinburgh St Andrew Square if

  • you want to spend less: about €387 a night less at the reference rate
  • you trust a bigger review base (6,035 reviews)

Guests praise

  • Location: Central, quiet square near trams, trains, shops, and main attractions.
  • Breakfast: Continental buffet offers a wide variety of cold options, coffee, and fresh items.

Guests criticise

  • Room Size: Often compact with limited floor space for luggage, though some units are spacious.
Luxury pick

Choose Gleneagles Townhouse if

  • guest reviews matter most to you (9.4 vs 8.8)
  • you want a 5-star hotel
  • spa is listed here and not at ibis Styles Edinburgh St Andrew Square
  • fitness centre is listed here and not at ibis Styles Edinburgh St Andrew Square

Guests praise

  • Staff: Friendly, attentive team provide a warm welcome, helpful concierge, and evening turndown service.
  • Location: Central position near Waverley station, within walking distance of the castle and major sights.

Guests criticise

  • Rooftop Bar: Exclusive terrace offers city views and cocktails, though space is small and service sometimes slow.

Frequently asked

Which is cheaper, ibis Styles Edinburgh St Andrew Square or Gleneagles Townhouse?
ibis Styles Edinburgh St Andrew Square had the lower reference rate: €184 a night against €571 (rate checked on 21 Nov 2026 for 15–17 Dec 2026, 2 adults, 1 room). Check the booking link for your own dates.
Which has better reviews?
Gleneagles Townhouse scores 9.4/10 from 451 reviews; ibis Styles Edinburgh St Andrew Square scores 8.8/10 from 6,035 reviews (Booking.com).
How far apart are they?
About 196 m in a straight line, roughly 3 min on foot.

More in Edinburgh

Sources: guest scores, review counts, star ratings, facilities and prices from Booking.com (catalogue data checked in September and October 2026, prices refreshed by our weekly live check); landmark coordinates from Wikipedia; distances are straight-line estimates and walking times assume 4.8 km/h on a 30% longer route. Page data rebuilt 21 Nov 2026. Some links earn us a commission, which never changes the picks. How we choose.