Home › United States › New York › Pod Times Square vs The Knickerbocker Hotel
New York, United States · Head to head
Pod Times Square vs The Knickerbocker Hotel.
Two of our three New York picks compared on the numbers: the Budget pick against the Luxury pick.
The Knickerbocker Hotel has the higher guest score (8.7/10 from 2,217 reviews against 8.6 for Pod Times Square). Pod Times Square is cheaper: €220 a night against €637 (rate checked on 21 Nov 2026 for 15–17 Dec 2026, 2 adults, 1 room). The Knickerbocker Hotel is closer to Times Square (about 4 min on foot).
Side by side
| Pod Times Square | The Knickerbocker Hotel | |
|---|---|---|
| Our pick | Budget | Luxury |
| Area | Manhattan | Manhattan |
| Stars | 3 (official) | 5 (official) |
| Guest score | 8.6 | 8.7 |
| Reviews | 16,603 | 2,217 |
| Location score | 9.5 | 9.5 |
| Reference rate / night | €220 | €637 |
| Price check 21 Nov 2026 (15–17 Dec 2026) | €220 | €637 |
| To Times Square | 623 m · 10 min | 217 m · 4 min |
| To Madison Square Garden | 873 m · 14 min | 834 m · 14 min |
| Pets allowed | Yes | Yes |
| Family rooms | Not listed | Yes |
| Fitness centre | Not listed | Yes |
| Breakfast available | Not listed | Yes |
| Air conditioning | Yes | Yes |
The two hotels are about 655 m apart.
Choose Pod Times Square if
- you want to spend less: about €417 a night less at the reference rate
- you trust a bigger review base (16,603 reviews)
Guests praise
- Location: Walking distance to Times Square, Broadway theaters, and subway stations.
- Room Cleanliness: Tidy and well-maintained spaces with daily housekeeping services.
Guests criticise
- Value For Money: Affordable rates for the area, though some guests report hidden fees and high deposits.
Choose The Knickerbocker Hotel if
- guest reviews matter most to you (8.7 vs 8.6)
- you want a 5-star hotel
- you want to be near Times Square (4 min on foot)
- fitness centre is listed here and not at Pod Times Square
Guests praise
- Location: Central setting on Times Square near subway stations and major attractions.
- Staff: Friendly, professional team provides helpful service and attentive housekeeping.
Guests criticise
- Value For Money: High rates for rooms and dining do not match the limited amenities provided.
Frequently asked
- Which is cheaper, Pod Times Square or The Knickerbocker Hotel?
- Pod Times Square had the lower reference rate: €220 a night against €637 (rate checked on 21 Nov 2026 for 15–17 Dec 2026, 2 adults, 1 room). Check the booking link for your own dates.
- Which has better reviews?
- The Knickerbocker Hotel scores 8.7/10 from 2,217 reviews; Pod Times Square scores 8.6/10 from 16,603 reviews (Booking.com).
- How far apart are they?
- About 655 m in a straight line, roughly 11 min on foot.
More in New York
- The 3 best hotels in New York
- Pod Times Square vs Hampton Inn Times Square Central
- Hampton Inn Times Square Central vs The Knickerbocker Hotel
- Day trips from New York
- Hotel statistics for United States
Sources: guest scores, review counts, star ratings, facilities and prices from Booking.com (catalogue data checked in September and October 2026, prices refreshed by our weekly live check); landmark coordinates from Wikipedia; distances are straight-line estimates and walking times assume 4.8 km/h on a 30% longer route. Page data rebuilt 21 Nov 2026. Some links earn us a commission, which never changes the picks. How we choose.