Home › United States › New York › Pod Times Square vs The Knickerbocker Hotel

New York, United States · Head to head

Pod Times Square vs The Knickerbocker Hotel.

Two of our three New York picks compared on the numbers: the Budget pick against the Luxury pick.

The Knickerbocker Hotel has the higher guest score (8.7/10 from 2,217 reviews against 8.6 for Pod Times Square). Pod Times Square is cheaper: €220 a night against €637 (rate checked on 21 Nov 2026 for 15–17 Dec 2026, 2 adults, 1 room). The Knickerbocker Hotel is closer to Times Square (about 4 min on foot).

Scores and reference rates: Booking.com, checked 14 Oct 2026. Prices: rate checked on 21 Nov 2026 for 15–17 Dec 2026, 2 adults, 1 room; not live quotes.

Side by side

Pod Times SquareThe Knickerbocker Hotel
Our pickBudgetLuxury
AreaManhattanManhattan
Stars3 (official)5 (official)
Guest score8.68.7
Reviews16,6032,217
Location score9.59.5
Reference rate / night€220€637
Price check 21 Nov 2026 (15–17 Dec 2026)€220€637
To Times Square623 m · 10 min217 m · 4 min
To Madison Square Garden873 m · 14 min834 m · 14 min
Pets allowedYesYes
Family roomsNot listedYes
Fitness centreNot listedYes
Breakfast availableNot listedYes
Air conditioningYesYes

The two hotels are about 655 m apart.

Budget pick

Choose Pod Times Square if

  • you want to spend less: about €417 a night less at the reference rate
  • you trust a bigger review base (16,603 reviews)

Guests praise

  • Location: Walking distance to Times Square, Broadway theaters, and subway stations.
  • Room Cleanliness: Tidy and well-maintained spaces with daily housekeeping services.

Guests criticise

  • Value For Money: Affordable rates for the area, though some guests report hidden fees and high deposits.
Luxury pick

Choose The Knickerbocker Hotel if

  • guest reviews matter most to you (8.7 vs 8.6)
  • you want a 5-star hotel
  • you want to be near Times Square (4 min on foot)
  • fitness centre is listed here and not at Pod Times Square

Guests praise

  • Location: Central setting on Times Square near subway stations and major attractions.
  • Staff: Friendly, professional team provides helpful service and attentive housekeeping.

Guests criticise

  • Value For Money: High rates for rooms and dining do not match the limited amenities provided.

Frequently asked

Which is cheaper, Pod Times Square or The Knickerbocker Hotel?
Pod Times Square had the lower reference rate: €220 a night against €637 (rate checked on 21 Nov 2026 for 15–17 Dec 2026, 2 adults, 1 room). Check the booking link for your own dates.
Which has better reviews?
The Knickerbocker Hotel scores 8.7/10 from 2,217 reviews; Pod Times Square scores 8.6/10 from 16,603 reviews (Booking.com).
How far apart are they?
About 655 m in a straight line, roughly 11 min on foot.

More in New York

Sources: guest scores, review counts, star ratings, facilities and prices from Booking.com (catalogue data checked in September and October 2026, prices refreshed by our weekly live check); landmark coordinates from Wikipedia; distances are straight-line estimates and walking times assume 4.8 km/h on a 30% longer route. Page data rebuilt 21 Nov 2026. Some links earn us a commission, which never changes the picks. How we choose.